Home >> Students >> Global Issues >> Urban Life >> Urban Legends  
 

Find Out More

   Urban Legends: New York and Shanghai


New York - Shanghai Student Forum

Sister Cities What do New
York and Shanghai have in common?

Urban Dreams Why do
people move to the city?

My City What is life like in
New York and Shanghai?

Cities of the Future How can youth change the city?

 

Are there any similarities between the "urban legends" about different cities?  

Disposable Planet and Urban Planet
BBC News

Cities Without Slums
The City Alliance

Explore Your City and Others Google Earth

 
Why do you think these similarities may exist?
Do you think "urban legends" can tell you something about a particular city?
 

New York students talk about what others say about NYC
 

Cities are not only physical spaces, but they also exist as concepts in the minds of residents and outsiders. Have you ever thought about "New York" or "Shanghai" as an idea, not a place?

Think about what people commonly say about your city and its residents. These perceptions may come from popular slogans and songs, news or media, historical events, or simply generalizations. Do any hold true? Are any misguided or even unfounded?

What are some impressions you have of other cities, even though you may

 
More Features
  Shanghai
Metropolitan Idol
 
  Singapore
Tough Love in the Nanny State
 
  Beijing
Life in the New China
 


Get the Facts

Map of China

Map of the United States

Map of Shanghai

Map of New York City

Shanghai timeline

New York City timeline

 

have never been there? If you had a chance to talk to others
about their perceptions of your city or your perceptions of their
city, what would you ask?

Here some "urban legends" about Shanghai:

  • Shanghai is the Paris of China.
  • In Guangdong (in south China) they eat anything; in Beijing (the capital of China) they say anything; in Shanghai they wear anything.
  • If you want to make money, go to Shanghai.

 

Here is what Jiaxing, Jinyu, and Benqing from Shanghai had to say about the urban legend that Shanghai is one of the world's most modern cities:

"About traditions and festivals, it seems that foreigners like it, we Chinese ignore it. But the truth is that from the bottom of our heart, we originally have it. As what we have said, try to keep some, try to break some. Places like Xintiandi shows that we no more ignore the architectural heritage of our culture. People like Shikumen, some houses of classical style, also essential of the culture.

[Note: Xintiandi is a pedestrian area of Shanghai where traditional houses from the mid 19th century have been preserved and renovated to include shops, restaurants, and theaters, similar to South Street Seaport in New York. These traditional houses are called shikumen or “stone gate” houses. They were mostly built by the British for Chinese workers who moved to Shanghai in the early 1900s, and they illustrate Shanghai's cosmopolitan history through their blend of eastern and western architectural styles.]

We appreciate our city not only because of its modernization. The character which Shanghai have is different from NY’s. At a word, we have history. Yu Garden as well as Jinan Temple is the calling card of Shanghai. The foreigners seem very curious about them. But what about our youths? Fewer youths are familiar with the gorgeous history. To make our city a better one, we hope youths to learn more about our history. To protect the old buildings and to inherit the tradition is demand for all of us. Since we’ve been both stylish and traditional, our city would be shaped as a individual place."

 

 

Copyright 2006. Author: Heather Clydesdale